Lighthouse News Daily

Breaking Daily News

Tuesday, March 2, 2021
Log in
  • Headlines
  • Business
  • Education
  • Entertainment
  • Sports
  • Technology
  • U.S.
  • World
  • Latest News
    • Inflatable Greenhouse Could Be A Food Source In The Outer Space
    • YouTube for Children Being Launched by Google
    • Some Animals Produce Natural Sunscreen to Protect Themselves from Radiation, New Study Shows
    • A New Genetic Map Tracks Down Dog Breeds And Their Evolution
    • Lack Of Sleep Causes Brain Cells To Slow Down
    • Meet Lyuba, the Best-Preserved Baby Mammoth in the World
    • Reports of Great White Shark Spottings Around Wells, Maine
    • Minecraft Adds Hour of Code Designer Tutorial
    • The de Broglie-Bohm Theory Is Back and It’s Surreal
    • Could High Carbon Dioxide Concentration Make Earth Greener?
You are here: Home / Science / Scientists Speak Out About Inaccurate Climate Change Textbooks

Scientists Speak Out About Inaccurate Climate Change Textbooks

November 25, 2015 By Joseph Decker Leave a Comment

Email, RSS Follow
Scientists speak out about inaccurate climate change textbooks, noting that more often than not the language used is creating uncertainty and presenting opinions over scientific facts.

Scientists speak out about inaccurate climate change textbooks, noting that more often than not the language used is creating uncertainty and presenting opinions over scientific facts.

Scientists speak out about inaccurate climate change textbooks, noting that more often than not the language used is creating uncertainty and presenting opinions over scientific facts.

The study, conducted by K.C. Busch and Diego Roman of Stanford University and Southern Methodist University respectively, looked at four of the climate change textbooks in California and analyzed the use of language presenting the accuracy of scientific facts. Unfortunately they reached the conclusion that climate change textbooks are misrepresenting the science. Although they should be science textbooks, science is sidelined, making way for interpretation of debates surrounding climate science.

The research is published in the Environmental Education Research journal. The authors highlighted how through the use of language the climate change textbooks are more intimate with the public debate rather than informing on the scientific facts underpinning climate change.

A few notable examples of language creating uncertainty have been picked by the authors and presented to the public. Language choices in the four climate change textbooks portray the issue as uncertain on several levels. If it’s taken word by word, the way language is used inflicts doubt on whether climate change is happening, whether the human activity is really causing it or not or how disastrous the effects could be.

The textbooks under the limelight are the go to resource for sixth graders in California. All have been written and published in 2007 and 2008. These are Focus on Earth Science (Prentice Hall, 2008), Focus on Earth Science (CPO Science, 2007), Focus on Earth Science (Glencoe-McGraw-Hill, 2007) and Earth Science (Holt, Rinehart, Winston, 2007).

Presented to sixth graders in their formative years, the climate change textbooks are prone to influence their thinking on the issue. Considering that 54 percent of American teens declare climate change isn’t happening, while another 43 percent are reluctant to the idea that it is human activity-driven, one of the sources forming these opinions are textbooks.

Of the four climate change textbooks, the authors picked 279 clauses amounting to a total of 2,770 words. None of them were decisive or fact-based on any course of action. May, might, possibly, possible, unclear, some, not at all are common words associated with climate change.

This choice of language is not indicative of scientific facts. It is rather a review of debates and beliefs which do little to help the understanding of the issue. None of the climate change sections in the four climate change textbooks were decisive on ways to address climate change and human response. Moreover, the topic was approached more from a skeptic perspective stating that it ‘might be happening’ or that human activity either may or may not cause climate change.

By comparison, the UN IPCC studies involving over 600 scientists worldwide were not mentioned. Between ‘some scientists argue that climate change isn’t happening’ and the reality of the IPCC where 3 percent of the scientists approach climate change in a moderate fashion, there is a large gap for misinterpretation due to uncertainty.

Scientists speak out about inaccurate climate change textbooks, declaring at the same time that a textbooks should read as an encyclopedia of scientific facts. Declarative sentences with the role of a definition should be the golden rule. However, the four climate change textbooks are brimming with modal verbs or indeterminate quantifiers.

Photo Credits: Wikimedia

Email, RSS Follow

Filed Under: Science Tagged With: Calfornia, Climate Change, four climate change textbooks, language, Scientists Speak Out About Inaccurate Climate Change Textbooks, uncertainty

Pages

  • About/Contact
  • AccomplishNow Sandra Rechsteiner | A Journey to Self-Acceptance
  • Privacy Policy GDPR
  • Staff
  • Terms and Conditions

Subscribe to Blog via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 17 other subscribers

Tablet Shipments Worldwide Drop for First Time

February 3, 2015 By David Kellen Leave a Comment

Feed Your Kids Allergenic Foods to Shield Them from Allergies

October 20, 2015 By Barbara Mast Leave a Comment

Kurt Busch Says Ex-Girlfriend Was an Assassin

January 14, 2015 By David Kellen Leave a Comment

Conrad Hilton, Younger Brother of Paris Charged

February 4, 2015 By Barbara Mast Leave a Comment

Speed Looked at as Possible Factor in Crash Killing Bob Simon

February 12, 2015 By Joseph Decker Leave a Comment

Hottest Year on Record

January 16, 2015 By David Kellen Leave a Comment

Leaderboards are not exactly the essence of a new Diablo III season, but just a reason to start fresh.

Diablo III “Seasons” Might Hit the Consoles

August 22, 2015 By Lonnie Davidson Leave a Comment

Lululemon Founder Leaving Board, Keeps Stake in Business

February 2, 2015 By Janice Bower Leave a Comment

Related Articles

  • Hunterian Museum, where the skeleton of the Irish Giant is kept

    Irish Giant Skeleton Could Be Buried at Sea

    Jun 27, 2018
  • part of a Leonardo Da Vinci painting

    Painted Tile Might be Leonardo Da Vinci’s Earliest Work

    Jun 27, 2018
  • Robert F. Kennedy

    More Details on Robert F. Kennedy’s Assassination Emerge (Study)

    Jun 20, 2018
  • cat and dog

    Dogs Have More Neurons than Cats (Study)

    Jun 18, 2018
  • Stephen Hawking

    Stephen Hawking’s Voice to Be Beamed into Space

    Jun 15, 2018
  • cat's blue eyes

    Why Do Humans See Better Than Other Animals? (Study)

    Jun 7, 2018
  • ice shelf in East Antarctica

    Earthquakes are Happening Beneath East Antarctica’s Ice (Study)

    Jun 6, 2018
  • mother with her baby

    Women’s Voices Drop After Giving Birth (Study)

    Jun 4, 2018
  • human evolution

    Why Do Humans Have Big Brains? Experts Weigh In (Study)

    May 24, 2018
  • Adolf Hitler and Eva Braun with dogs

    Adolf Hitler’s Teeth Confirm He Indeed Died in 1945 (Study)

    May 23, 2018

Categories

  • Business
  • Education
  • Entertainment
  • Headlines
  • Health
  • Nature
  • Science
  • Sports
  • Technology
  • U.S.
  • Uncategorized
  • World

Copyright © 2021 lighthousenewsdaily.com

About | Contact · Staff · Terms and Conditions · Privacy Policy

This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. Learn more.